Eye Makeup Safety: FDA Tips for Mascara and Eyeliner
FDA tips for eye makeup safety: when to replace mascara, why not to share eyeliner, storage limits, and when to stop and see a doctor.
Eye makeup sits closer to the eye than any other cosmetic, so the habits around it matter as much as the product. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) gives a short list of safety tips for mascara, eyeliner, and other eye cosmetics: replace mascara every two to four months, never share eye makeup, wash your hands before applying, and stop using anything that irritates your eyes. This guide walks through those tips in order, with the reason behind each one.
What the FDA Says About Eye Cosmetics
Most eye cosmetics are safe when used properly. The trouble starts with misuse, because a product that picks up bacteria or fungi can pass them to the eye area. In rare cases, women have been temporarily or permanently blinded by an infection from an eye cosmetic, according to the FDA.
The risk builds after a product is opened. Every time a mascara wand goes back into the tube, it carries bacteria with it, and every time a pencil is shared, it carries someone else's bacteria.
The FDA also notes that cosmetic products and ingredients, other than color additives, are not required to be approved by the agency before they are sold in stores. That puts more weight on the buyer's own habits.
This guide makes no treatment claim, and nothing here is medical advice.
Safe Habits vs Risky Habits for Eye Makeup
| Habit | What the FDA says | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Replace mascara | Discard 2 to 4 months after purchase | Each use exposes the wand to bacteria and fungi |
| Share eye makeup | Do not share or swap, not even with a friend | Another person's bacteria may be hazardous to you |
| Wash hands first | Wash hands before applying, keep applicators clean | Bacteria on hands can reach the eye area |
| Revive dried mascara | Do not add saliva or water | Saliva adds germs, water dilutes the preservative |
| Store in a hot car | Do not store above 85 degrees F | Heat can weaken the preservative |
The first row is the one people miss most often. Mascara has the shortest safe life of any eye product, because the wand goes in and out of the tube every day. The other rows are about keeping new germs out: other people's germs, germs from unwashed hands, germs from saliva or tap water, and heat.
Mascara: The Two-to-Four-Month Rule
Manufacturers usually recommend discarding mascara two to four months after purchase, according to the FDA. Each time you use mascara, the wand is exposed to bacteria and fungi.
Two more FDA rules go with the replacement rule.
- Do not add saliva or water to dried-up mascara. Bacteria from your mouth may grow in the product, and adding water may introduce bacteria and dilute the preservative that protects against microbial growth.
- Throw away your eye makeup if you get an eye infection. The products may have become contaminated.
If the mascara changes color or smell, or turns dry or clumpy before the window ends, it makes sense to discard it early.
Eyeliner and Applicators
Eyeliner follows the same hygiene rules, although the FDA page gives a replacement interval for mascara only. Replace liners on a regular schedule and after any eye infection.
Do not use cosmetics near your eyes unless they are meant for your eyes. For example, do not use lip liner on your eyes.
Wash your hands before applying, and make sure any instrument you place in the eye area is clean. A liquid liner applicator goes back into the bottle the same way a mascara wand does, so the same freshness logic applies.
Never apply or remove eye cosmetics in a moving vehicle. A bump or sudden stop can injure the eye with a wand or other applicator.
Home Lash and Brow Dye, and Kohl
Do not dye or tint your eyebrows or eyelashes at home, says the FDA. The one color additive the agency allows for this use, silver nitrate, is restricted to up to 4 percent by weight in a viscous gel product.
Kohl, also sold as kajal or surma, deserves extra care. The FDA says to keep kohl away from children, since reports have linked it to lead poisoning. Check the product's label and keep it away from the eye area.
When to Stop and Ask a Doctor
If any eye cosmetic causes irritation, stop using it immediately. If irritation persists, see a doctor.
Avoid eye cosmetics while you have an eye infection or the skin around the eye is inflamed. Wait until the area has healed, and discard the products you were using when the infection started.
If a reaction is severe, with swelling, vision changes, or pain that does not fade, seek care promptly and bring the product with you. If you have an eye condition, are pregnant, or take medication that affects your eyes, ask a clinician before trying a new eye cosmetic.
Before You Buy
- Note the purchase date, and plan to replace mascara every two to four months.
- Read the full ingredient list on the brand's official product page, because formulas change and shade lists vary by region.
- Choose products labeled for the eye area, and skip kohl and home lash or brow dyes.
- Keep the receipt and the box until you know the product agrees with your eyes.
- See official site for the current FDA eye cosmetic safety tips before buying.
FAQ
How often should I replace mascara? Manufacturers usually recommend discarding mascara two to four months after purchase, according to the FDA. Mark the opening date on the tube, and discard it sooner if it dries out, changes color or smell, or you had an eye infection while using it.
Can I add water to dried mascara to make it last longer? No. The FDA advises against adding saliva or water to mascara. Saliva can add germs from your mouth, and water can introduce bacteria and dilute the preservative. Discard dried-up mascara instead.
What should I do if my eyes get irritated after using eye makeup? Stop using the product immediately. If irritation persists, see a doctor. Avoid eye cosmetics until the area has healed, and discard the products you were using when the irritation appeared.